Question Tag: Auditor's Rights

Phil Plc has been in business of manufacturing textile materials for about twenty years and has been rendering good returns to shareholders on their investments until about a few years ago, precisely in 2019. The business of the company went down drastically in 2020 due to measures taken to contain the spread of the COVID-19 virus, which included travel bans, quarantines, social distancing, and closures of non-essential services. The COVID-19 pandemic significantly caused disruptions to businesses worldwide, resulting in economic slowdown. The problem was aggravated with the Federal Government of Nigeria enforcing restrictions on movement. All businesses and offices were affected with exceptions of power distribution, oil and gas (petroleum), and retail companies.

COVID-19 pandemic impacted the economy generally, and the following were the impacts on the company:

• Increase in cost of raw materials as a result of devaluation of the currency due to the drop in the price of crude oil;
• Shortage in supply of key raw materials sourced from other countries, for example, China; and
• Increase in ocean freight costs and inland transportation.

The impact of the outbreak of COVID-19 directly caused economic losses through disruptions in supply chains, demand, and financial markets, affecting business investment, household consumption, and international trade. The crisis led to a decline in revenue.

However, despite the challenges, management continued to strive for impressive performance for the shareholders. A board member believed there is an unhealthy relationship between management and the board of directors as she accused management of lack of transparency and threatened to resign. The problem was compounded after the year-end audit when the auditors reported that the company’s internal controls were ineffective and accused management of fraudulent financial reporting. The external auditors also threatened to restate the prior year’s financial statements, believing there were misstatements of certain account balances.

The Managing Director and some directors argued that it is their responsibility to prepare financial statements and that auditors do not have the right to make restatements. However, the Chairman of the audit committee and a few directors supported the auditors and appealed to management to allow the auditors to perform their regulated duties, warning that they may report to the Financial Reporting Council on management’s activities.

The external auditors, surprised by management’s actions, threatened to resign. They were also uncomfortable with the following issues during the audit:

• The supporting documents from which financial statements were prepared;
• Review of opening balances revealing omission of some transactions and significant information in disclosures;
• Misapplication of accounting principles regarding amounts, classifications, presentation, and disclosures.

Added to the above, the external auditors identified risks likely affecting asset valuation and other significant accrued liabilities. Your firm is preparing for a discussion with the audit committee and has instructed your team to review specific sections.

Required:

a. Evaluate the rights and duties of the auditors in a professional engagement. (10 Marks)

b. Enumerate what you consider as the responsibilities of management and those charged with governance in Phil Plc. (5 Marks)

c. Discuss the reason why your firm may resign the appointment as the auditors of the company. (5 Marks)
(Total 20 Marks)